The Exchange with Ed Stetzer

Anthony Bradley: Can the Church Teach Dads to Be Warm?

Episode Summary

Anthony Bradley argues a father can live at home and still leave his children deprived, and that Christian parenting has prized order over warmth. Drawing on thirty years of teaching and mentoring young men, Bradley names three practices that make fathers effective: presence, warmth, and joy, none of which cost money or require training. He argues that a generation of Christian parenting books taught discipline while neglecting affection, that roughhousing builds impulse control, and that for faith persistence into adulthood a father’s influence outweighs even a devout mother’s. Anthony Bradley is a distinguished research fellow at the Acton Institute and research professor of interdisciplinary and theological studies at Kuyper College. His book The Fatherhood Effect draws on three decades of teaching in Christian schools, colleges, and seminaries and mentoring young men in Harlem, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Chattanooga, and St. Louis.

Episode Notes

Many leaders have launched fatherhood initiatives, but the problem persists. Anthony Bradley says the missing piece is affection, and that the church holds more of the remedy than public policy does.

The conversation

What is the difference between father absence and dad deprivation?
Bradley once framed the issue as fatherlessness, and audiences pictured low-income households. The research changed his language. A father can share a home with his children and give them no attachment, and some mental health outcomes for those children track closely with outcomes for children whose fathers are gone. To be dad deprived is to grow up without a father’s voice telling you that you matter, giving direction, and forming your faith. Ed describes his own childhood in these terms: a father in the house and distant through years of alcoholism.

What makes a father effective?
Bradley names three practices: presence without phones or screens, warmth that makes a father a refuge, and joy in the children themselves. He cites research tying roughhousing to impulse control and emotional regulation, and to lower rates of porn and video game addiction in boys. He contrasts this with Christian parenting literature from the late 1990s and 2000s, which taught discipline and order and said little about hugs, eye contact, or curiosity about a child’s inner life.

Should pastors promote marriage, fatherhood, or both?
Bradley describes concentric circles: marriage, then motherhood and fatherhood, then the raising of children. A wife supplies support and insight a father cannot gather alone, and children who see their parents in love feel secure. 

From the conversation

“You can have a dad in the home and that father not be fathering at all.” - Anthony Bradley

“You can have the most spiritually vibrant mom on the planet Earth, which is great. But in terms of faith persistence from childhood into adulthood, it’s the father that matters more.” - Anthony Bradley

“There is no law, there is no public policy that can generate greater affection between fathers and their children.” - Anthony Bradley

“Youth ministry is actually part of the problem. Because a lot of youth ministry wedges children and isolates them from adult relationships and keeps them quarantined with their peers for way too much time.” - Anthony Bradley

About Anthony Bradley

Anthony Bradley is a distinguished research fellow at the Acton Institute and research professor of interdisciplinary and theological studies at Kuyper College. He previously directed the Center for the Study of Human Flourishing at The King’s College and writes on fatherhood, the crisis facing men and boys, criminal justice reform, and race in America. His books include Heroic Fraternities and The Fatherhood Effect.

Episode Transcription

[00:00:00] Anthony Bradley: We've got churches full of men sitting in the pews. And they don't know that they're needed. There's just a lot of children, particularly from homes where there's a lot of dysfunction or brokenness, where these men can really come in and be a father figure for that particular child.

[00:00:06] Ed Stetzer: Talk about fatherhood these days. I mean, a lot of people have strong opinions on it. This is what's wrong with America. This is what's wrong with this community, is the absence of fathers and the presence of fathers. Well, does that bring about substantial change? Does that bring about community transformation?

Well, our guest today makes that case. Anthony Bradley is our guest. He is a distinguished research fellow at the Acton Institute and a research professor of interdisciplinary and theological studies at Kuyper College. His new book is "The Fatherhood Effect," and we're having this conversation about fatherhood, faith, if you're a pastor and church leader, about how you can help instill and call fathers up to who they are in Christ, but also invite others to be that father figure in the lives of young men who, as we'll see from the research, really need that. So thanks for joining us on "The Exchange" with Ed Stetzer, brought to you by Gloo.

All right, Anthony Bradley, you are a fascinating follow on the socials. I'm always out there watching you, and you're the king of the rhetorical question. Why are they doing this? What does this mean? I think you're meaning them rhetorically often at times, but you kind of start conversations, you engage conversations. But now I'm kind of fascinated by your book and the kind of conversation that's going to facilitate as well.

[00:01:42] The book, of course, is called "The Fatherhood Effect: The Consequences of a Dad-Deprived Culture and Practical Strategies for Positive Change." All right. So first, thanks for coming on "The Exchange," with Ed Stetzer. I think everyone sort of agrees with, that fathers are important. George W. Bush had a fatherhood initiative and a marriage initiative, if I recall. Barack Obama had a fatherhood initiative. So I don't know that people disagree with fathers are important, but you say the most, I'm quoting, "The most important men in any community, anywhere, ever," unquote, is fathers. And without them, there's a major, unrecognized driver of harm to children, to communities, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Okay. So that being said, first, thank you for joining us, and tell me what kind of inspired you to step into this space?

[00:02:31] Bradley: Great question, and thanks again for having me on. I have been teaching the children of the church for 30 years, and I've seen young men struggling for 30 years. And I've been in ministry contexts. I've taught at Christian schools, I've taught at seminaries, I've taught at Christian colleges, and I've seen the exact same pattern for the last 30 years. Young men are struggling. Young women aren't. And as I began to sort of dig back in the data, I began to kind of connect the dots, and it goes back to dads.

I was doing criminal justice work. 70% of the kids in the juvenile system, no dads. I was doing a lot of work in terms of mentoring, young men in Harlem. What did I see when I was in New York, in Harlem? The guys who were struggling, violence, drugs, et cetera. No dads. I've also been in middle class context and have been mentoring a lot of young guys of seminary professors and CEOs and lawyers and doctors. Same pattern. They're all struggling. Why? No dad attachment. And so those are some of the things that really came to the front for me, regardless of race, class, location. I've seen the pattern in Philadelphia, I've seen it in Atlanta, I've seen it in Chattanooga, I've seen it in St. Louis. It's pretty, pretty universal. So that's what really drove me to the topic.

[00:03:50] Stetzer: I had a very close relationship with my dad. He died not long ago, and I shared a little bit about that. But when I was a kid, I was dad deprived. My father was there, but he would later tell the story. He was kind of in the throes of alcoholism and, you know, it just was distant father. And so I didn't have father absence. My parents divorced later, then it was father absence. But definitely dad deprivation. And you make the distinction between those two that I found helpful when I was reading the book. So unpack that, what that means.

[00:04:19] Bradley: Yeah. You know, I used to talk about this in terms of fatherlessness, and immediately people began to think of low-income, kids in inner cities or in Appalachia or something like that. And what the research shows that really kind of blew my mind is that you can have a dad in the home and he cannot be attached to his kids. He can not have connection with them. You can have a dad in the home and that father not be fathering at all, right? Physically present, emotionally distant, things like that. And so you can have a father in the home and still be dad deprived.

And the research is really interesting because in some cases, there's not much difference in some of the mental health outcomes for kids when the dad is totally absent, that is physically absent, or versus when he's physically present in the home, but also not fathering. So dad deprivation is a much better distinction to talk about the sorts of dads who are not attached to their kids, whether they live in the home or not.

[00:05:21] Stetzer: So what does it then mean? What is it like to be dad-deprived?

[00:05:24] Bradley: That term sort of in the psych data really does talk about and sort of explain a context where you're sort of lacking deep connection with your father. You don't have your father's voice to tell you that you matter. You don't have your father's voice to give you self-confidence. You don't have your father's voice for direction. You don't have your father's voice for spiritual formation. He's just not around for the things that kids need as they develop. And so to be dad-deprived is to be deprived of a father's voice and presence at the stages of life when you're growing up, when you really need him from birth until early adulthood.

[00:06:04] Stetzer: You know, it's interesting, my dad, you know, we became very close later. He was a great grandfather. And one time we were talking, and I tried to say to him, encourage him once, "Well, you were a good dad." And he said, "No, I wasn't a good dad." Then we talked about it, though. Part of it was his own childhood. You know, his father, he never heard his father say, "I love you." And so those were always things that were hard for him to say.

In some sense, there are dads listening, and they're like, "How do I break that cycle?" And you highlight, I mean, I think your stuff on roughhousing is really fascinating. We're going to get to that in a minute. But you kind of say in your stress, quote, "Mere physical presence of fathers is insufficient," unquote. And then earlier in the book, you quote Nancy Pearcey, because most of my audience are pastors or church leaders. But you quote Nancy Pearcey as saying a father, quote, "Can be a pillar of the church," and she goes on to say, "And have perfectly correct theology, but if he's perceived as cold and distant, the child will not follow him," unquote.

It's not presence. It's not, in the case of a lot of our listeners, it's not just being there, but being maybe distant and unengaged. But then on social media, you're always talking about roughhousing. So how does that all relate? Tie these things together for us.

[00:07:06] Bradley: Yeah. I think in a lot of Christian circles, and could have gone way back to some of these parenting books where a good father, sort of the stoic, he's sort of the in-house theologian, right? He's the Bible study leader. He may be the hymn singer, right? Or the one who leads prayers. But what the research shows is that the secret sauce in terms of effective fathering that leads to persistence in life for kids really involves three things, and these three things are really simple, and they're also free, by the way. Presence, warmth and joy. Presence, warmth and joy.

Presence is really simple. You have to physically be there, dads. You need to have a distraction free interact with your kids. There are no phones, no televisions. You're not listening to music. You're not doing anything else. It is a context in which your children experience the fact that you adore them, that you are pronounced over your kids, that you are my beloved son or daughter in human well pleased, and they feel that. So that's presence, is really engagement.

Number two is warmth. That is that your children know that you're a refuge, that you're a refuge and a strength in the time of trouble, right? They can come to you when life gets hard. They can come to you with questions. You're a rock for them, and you embrace them. There's a lot of affection. There's physical touch. There's hugs, right? There's words of endearment. There's words of encouragement. You are warm for them.

And then thirdly, joy. Like, enjoy your kids. Have fun with them. Laugh with them. Play with them. And what the research shows is that when dads do those three things, they pass on the values that they want to instill in their kids, whether it be social values, political values, faith persistence. Those are the three things that really do matter in terms of what makes effective fathers effective at transmitting these sorts of things. And again, it's free. You don't need a master's degree. And you can do it anywhere. You can do those things in a car on their way to soccer, in the kitchen, you go on a vacation, in the backyard where you're raking leaves. Like, the context really doesn't matter. But those are the three things that really do matter in terms of dads being effective.

[00:09:22] Stetzer: I told you, like roughhousing. I follow you on social media. You're always talking about roughhousing and the place of that. Again, this is one of those interviews where it's like I'm just processing all my father issues with you. But I mentioned this is not the first one, but I have no recollection of roughhousing with my father. I don't have any sons, I have all daughters. But you know, we have this thing called the Flying Wallendas, which is like I flip them and run around with them, et cetera, et cetera.

So for me, that was a way to articulate safety and risk and all those things that were there, which are some of the things you talk about. I'm just going to specifically, you know, quote what you say when you talk about these. So you talk about roughhousing and play and how fathers encouraged exploration, risk-taking, and independence. Now tie that to, because again, if people don't follow you on social media, they should, because, in addition to the rhetorical questions, this roughhousing and occasional references to fraternities make up a lot of your social media presence. So talk to us about roughhousing, how it fits.

[00:10:19] Bradley: Yeah, roughhousing is magical. It teaches the things that you mentioned. It also teaches delayed gratification. It teaches impulse control. It also teaches how to manage emotions, right? It teaches how to manage aggression, how to manage anger. The kids who wrestle a lot with their dads, they have a sense of their bodies matter, that their bodies can actually cause harm. When you're roughhousing your kids learn, "Oh, hey, you can't stick your elbow there. That hurts," right? "You can't put your finger there. That hurts Dad." So they kind of learn that their bodies can cause harm.

There are two hormones that are released in the context of rough and tumble play and roughhousing. One is oxytocin, which is the love hormone, and then secondly is dopamine, which is the feel-good hormone. So both the child and the parent are releasing these hormones. It does two things, right? It builds deeper connection, and they have fun. They actually enjoy it. Kids love to wrestle with their parents, and they love to wrestle with their dads. They really, really do love it.

And as you will remember, kids will kind of goat their dads into doing it, right? They'll poke them or tug on their shirt, and they'll say something like, "Hey, I bet you can't catch me," right? And then they kind of run slowly and waiting to tackle them. And what do you hear in the context of that? Just laughter. The kid's laughing, the dad's laughing, and it provides all of these positive variables and attributes, and no one knows this is happening, right? It just does. And the cool thing about this, like I said, it's free, and you can do this anywhere, in the kitchen, in the backyard, in the basement.

I often tell moms in churches, "Hey, you just have to be ready for the fact that some things may break," right? You may break a coffee table. You might get a leg on a couch that might get broken. But I'll tell you this. This is why this is important. You can repair a coffee table, but you really can't fix your child's soul, right? So on balance, if a broken coffee table contribute to your children doing well, I would say go ahead and let the table break.

Now, here's something that's really important, this is my last point here on this. What the research shows, is that boys who wrestle a lot with their fathers, who roughhouse a lot with their fathers, are less likely to suffer from porn addiction video game addiction. So the rough and tumble play and the roughhousing is an intervention against the future of addiction because it really does teach self-control and impulse control. And that's why I say it's magic and it's secret sauce in terms of kids thriving, and it's fun, right? I always encourage dads, as soon as they go home after hearing me speak, I say, "The first thing you do, right, grab one of your kids and just toss them in the air and just see what happens."

[00:13:09] Stetzer: Yeah. You know, I did that, but my wife was always a little bit freaked out by that, and I was okay with that. I would say that's what dads do and that was part of it as well. You're right on about page 38. You say, I'm quoting, "Researchers," quote, "are beginning to acknowledge that the data actually shows causation, not just correlation. The absence of a father truly causes the effects on children," unquote. You urge practitioners to treat father absence as a root cause rather than one correlate among many. So, and of course I mean, those are strong statements to say that this is so important that it has a connection, a causal connection between the two. But you're pointing out the fact that researchers are sort of even heading more in that direction.

So I guess the question is, you know, because we have all these fatherhood initiatives, like literally from presidents, what are we missing that they weren't already getting? How is it deeper than what we thought?

[00:14:02] Bradley: I think one of the things that's been missing, and you're definitely right, right? I mean, there's so many initiatives, especially in the mid-1990s, when the National Fatherhood Initiative was sort of born out of this era and many other things. I think the one thing that's been really missing, and Nancy Pearcey also brings this out in her book on masculinity, is affection. And I think one of the things that has been missing over the years is the importance of attachment and connection and affection. That's why I really did emphasize warmth in that earlier point, because it's really warm fathers that are a part of a conversation that we were not having about fathers in the late 90s and the early 2000s. And I think that one pivot, and the research has really borne this out, that really is the key driver of children being healthy.

And there are so many church communities, as you are well aware of, where that fatherly warmth is not cultivated from the pulpit. It's not coached in men's ministries or men's groups. It's not how dads are taught to father their children. If you read some of the parenting books from the late 1990s through the 2000s, there's a lot of talk again about discipline. There's a lot of talk about order. You're not going to read a lot about giving your children hugs, and asking them really good questions, and being curious about them, and showing eye contact, right? I mean, the research is really clear that you need to hug your kids at least for 20 seconds a day. 20 seconds. 20 seconds is the magic number for releasing dopamine and oxytocin, right? You need to make eye contact and to really be curious about them.

You know, one of the reasons that a lot of young adults today, I'm talking about Gen Z in particular, don't have good conversation skills because their fathers didn't show them how to do it, because their fathers weren't conversationalists. They taught them what to do, told them what to do, but they didn't really ask them questions. They didn't really pursue them. They didn't investigate their children's hearts and souls and minds, and that's how children learn how to interact with adults, and I think that's really been missing in terms of the way that so many of these books...

And listen, public policy cannot do this, right? So one of the things I focus on in the book is really focusing mostly on churches and nonprofits in terms of helping dads, because there is no law, there is no public policy that can generate greater affection between fathers and their children. We're back to the end of Malachi, right? Right? That when the prophet comes, what's going to happen? What's going to happen? That the hearts of the parents will be, right, toward their children, and their children to their parents. That right there is what's been missing, is that heart connection between parents and kids. And churches, I think, also don't do a good job of fostering that level of connection between parents and kids.

[00:16:58] Stetzer: Yeah, and 100%. And I do love when I see fatherhood-focused initiative. Now again, I don't want to leave out people without children. I want to recognize there's all kinds of expressions of people in the body of Christ. But fathers, I mean, I didn't get any training in being a dad, you know, just figured it out, struggled through it. And I think I would've been well-served if I had some mentors considering I didn't have a childhood, positive experience as well.

Whenever I talk to somebody, you know, for those who are listening and not necessarily watching, and we're talking here about, of course, fatherhood in general, but Anthony's African American, and one of the things I'm always cautious about like, well, let's talk about this in this space because you're African American. But your publisher puts here and does point out that 70% of the African American community and then 40% of Americans in general are born to single mothers. So I was intrigued to see that kind of drawn out there. Is there something that worth our deeper attention to ask what that looks like across racial and ethnic groups? Or how might we think about this?

[00:17:56] Bradley: Yes, and this goes back to the earlier distinction between dad deprivation and father absence, right? So while it's true that 70% of African American kids were born outside of the context of marriage, that does not mean that 70% of African American kids are fatherless or dad deprived, right? So for example, just because a man isn't married to the mother of the children doesn't mean he's not around and not engaged or attached to the kids, right?

He may come over three days a week. He may still be spending the night there. He actually may be living with the family. So the way in which we sort of categorize these households, that you could have a man not married to a woman giving birth to children in the home, and those children are marked as fatherless because they're born outside the context of marriage, okay? A study a few years ago showed that African American fathers on average they actually spend more time with their kids than white dads do.

[00:18:51] Stetzer: I actually saw you cite this on social media and it went crazy with people afterwards, yeah.

[00:18:55] Bradley: Right. And even though they may or may not be married to the mother of the child. So in the Black community, it's not so much necessarily father absence in terms of physically being connected. The real issue is marriage, and the erosion of marriage culture.

I'll tell you a quick story from Harlem. I'm in a church, and there's a young couple in the church, and they had twins, cute kids, and the father's working in a retail cell phone shop. The mother is also working in a retail space as well. They had two kids. They're living in a apartment, the subsidized housing. And I said, "Hey, listen, I will marry you guys at any moment," right? "We'll go down the courthouse and just, you know, get the paperwork done, and then we'll get you married." And they said, "No, we can't get married." And I said, "Well, what do you mean you can't get married? You're living together. You're basically married. You're basically a family." They said, "No, we'll lose our benefits."

That is, they'll lose their apartment. They'll lose their food subsidies. They'll have to move, and in New York City, you can't just move down the street, right? Too expensive. So they were completely disincentivized to get married, because they would lose their home and their communal connections because they'd have to actually physically move. So there have been, over the years, some policy implications that have undermined people's willingness to partner up and get married. And that's why I said earlier, again, you can be physically in the home and still be depriving your kids of your fatherly affections and attention.

[00:20:26] Stetzer: Yeah. So, the epilogue says fatherhood, quote, "Is not an institution that can be divorced from marriage without significant downgrades in quality and impact," unquote. And of course, you cite Wilcox and, you know, Brad Throut and that marriage premium, and more. So there clearly is a connection between the two. And I think this is where sometimes public policy has gotten tricky because are we promoting marriage? Are we promoting fatherhood? Or are we promoting fatherhood and marriage? So recognizing that sometimes this is not just a public policy discussion, but it's a local church setting as well. We'll get to the public policy thing. I do want to get to that. But as pastors and church leaders, should we be promoting marriage, fatherhood, or fatherhood and marriage, or how does that work?

[00:21:11] Bradley: Yes, and yes. All of it. So the research shows that the best dads are married dads, right? And so you want to be promoting marriage because marriage and family life, when a couple is committed to each other, provides the best context for men to be the best men that they can be, and for women to be the best women that they can be within the context of a family.

Who is it that provides the space and the contours and the opportunities for the father to be present and to be warm and to be joyful with his kids, right? Who provides the setting for that? It's his wife, right? And so they're working on this together, and so she's giving him encouragement, right? She's speaking words of affirmation. She's providing time. She's providing the resources, right? She's helping the dad do the job of fathering really well. In the context of a marriage, this is where dads really can thrive because they've got so much support with their wife, right, who is right there giving insight, right, giving words of encouragement, giving helpful perspective, right? She may have information about the kids that the dad can't get. She says, "Hey, talk to Johnny about this, talk to Mary about that." He may not know what's going on, but she may have some intuitions there, right? So that partnership really does make it better for the kids, and it just allows dads to thrive.

And so pastors really should be celebrating marriage, promoting marriage, but also promoting fatherhood as an extension of marriage, not as a separate institution in and of itself, right? So if you're a single dad, single dads do great. So these are sort of gradations of good, better, best, right? You can be a good dad, right? You can be a better dad. But the best dads, and this is what the research shows, the best dads are going to be within the context of marriage. And so churches really should think about this may perhaps in terms of concentric circles, where marriage is at the center. Motherhood and fatherhood, of course, extends from that, and raising the children within the context of those previous circles extends from that marriage as the center.

Last point here is that children, and we know this from, like, studies from here to the moon, show this, that children thrive when they know that their parents are in love with each other. When children can see and experience, when they feel that their parents' marriage is their priority in their family, they feel safe, they feel secure, they feel happy, they're less stressed, less anxious, less depressed, they do better in school, more likely to graduate from high school, more likely to graduate from college, more likely to get a job. I mean, more likely to have positive health outcomes, less likely to struggle with all sorts of issues because they know their parents are in love with each other. That's right.

So churches can really serve the kingdom and these families by really elevating and celebrating marriage. So one of the things I tell churches when I'm speaking in church, I'm like, "Dads and moms, listen, it's okay to gross your kids out every now and then, right?" They should be like, "Ew, would you guys stop it? Like, it's gross. Like, ugh, go get a room," right? That's good because on the one hand, they're saying, "Oh stop, this is grossing me out," but on the inside they're sighing relief that my life is in order, things are great, I've got... I can predict the future, there's hope because my parents are flirting with each other right in front of me. It really does secure them in pretty profound ways.

[00:24:58] Stetzer: You know, I don't know, my daughters are still rolling their eyes, but we're living into that and taking that as it goes. Okay. So I just wonder too, as you talk about fathers and you basically say, two places, you say fathers are irreplaceable and then mothers matter, quote, "But not as much as fathers," unquote.

I was just wondering, like, how much pushback do you get on these things? You know, I mentioned my own childhood, and then I was basically, you know, raised by a single mom for most of my childhood. I don't know if that math adds up on that, but for a lot of my childhood. And so, you know, I think of my mom as this heroic woman who's, you know, kind of walked through all this sort of stuff. So do you get pushback on the irreplaceable and mothers matter, but not as much?

[00:25:40] Bradley: It depends on the issue, right? So I often use it in terms of like a football analogy, right? So, let's say you're coming down the field, you're headed toward the end zone, you're in the red zone, you're on the 10-yard line. And yeah, moms can take you down to the 10-yard line, but what the research shows is that fathers are actually get you in the end zone on a few different variables, right? Faith persistence, mental health issues, education outcomes, sexual promiscuity, right? Those sorts of habits, drug use, alcohol use, whatever, it's not that moms are not important, but in terms of pushing some of these things over that line into thriving, it's really the dad that is such an important variable. If that were not true, then we wouldn't have the level of social pathologies that we see with kids who are just living in homes with single moms, right?

And it's really interesting that when we think about faith persistence in particular, what the research shows is that you can have the most spiritually vibrant mom on the planet Earth, which is great, but in terms of faith persistence from childhood into adulthood, it's the father that matters more. And when the kids experience the father's joy in his faith, the kids internalize that, they adopt that, they mimic that, and that's one of the key ingredients for faith persistence. It's, again, not that moms don't matter, but dads matter more on certain variables.

[00:27:15] Stetzer: So if you don't have a dad, and a lot of pastors are walking through situations where there are family members who don't have a dad, you know, maybe by death or divorce or whatever else it may be. What's the role of the church? And, you know, you say fathers are irreplaceable, but you also do say in elsewhere that male father figures can be significant influential. So talk to us a little bit about that, because the church can play a role in that.

[00:27:41] Bradley: The church should play a role in that. Actually, the church is the best place in terms of intervening in some brokenness, right? And I wrote about this a few months ago. We've got churches full of men sitting in the pews, or chairs, depending on what kind of church you're in, right? And they don't know that they're needed. They don't know that they're important. We often put them on the soundboard, or they fold up chairs or work the parking lot, but there's just a lot of children, particularly from homes where there's a lot of dysfunction or brokenness, where these men can really come in and be a father figure for that particular child, right?

There was a time in some higher church traditions where you had the role of godfather, right? Or, like, godmother. And what I'm really recommending is we kind of return to this idea that the children of the church belong not just to the parents, but to the entire church. And so when I talk about fatherhood, I'm talking about it as a vocation and an office. I mean it beyond the biological father, right? So you can be a dad in a church and be a father figure to a couple kids in the church. You can be a mentor, right? You can be a spiritual director, right? You can sort of be that role, that sort of spiritual sage figure for your own kids and somebody else's kids.

I think one of the things that churches need to do a much better job of is cultivating a context where children have better relationships with adults. And this is controversial what I'm about to say, but youth ministry is actually part of the problem because a lot of youth ministry wedges children and isolates them from adult relationships and keeps them quarantined with their peers for way too much time. So one of the things that I'm recommending is that around probably age 12, probably sixth grade, the boys need to be in the men's ministry, and the girls need to be in the women's ministry.

Because again, research is really clear on this. One of the things that contributes to young adults not leaving the church from the back door is connecting with their parents, being heavily influenced by their father, and then thirdly, having a strong network of older adults who know them and care about them. It's not youth ministry, it's not Sunday school, it's not the youth camp, it's not the missions trip. It's parents, and particularly the father, and older adults. Right out of Timothy, right? Older men teach younger men, older women teach younger women. That's what I think the church really needs to focus on if we want to begin to see more consistent thriving from childhood into adulthood on the issues of faith.

[00:30:34] Stetzer: So many questions I want to ask now that you brought up the student ministry thing at the end. I might differ some. You know, I think it's a bad thing when it's a four-year holding tank with pizza, but I think that intergenerational stuff, we actually see in the data that we did at LifeWay Research that intergenerational relationships make such a big difference. There are probably different ways to slice that, but okay. But it's interview with you rather than me giving all my opinions.

So last word from you. When I was distant from my father, particularly in my teenage years, there was a guy named Steve Morgan. If you actually look at my wedding pictures, it's a bunch of, you know, 20-year-old college buddies, and then this 45-year-old guy who's one of my groomsmen because he drove me, he chauffeured my girlfriend and me on a date. Like, he discipled me and more. So he, and later that girlfriend that I married, and he was in the wedding. You know, so how do we, as pastors and leaders, like, how do we call out and call up these men to be, well, I guess fathers to be fatherly, but also for others to step into lives and to be part of that community of fathering?

[00:31:37] Bradley: That's a great question. Again, I think first, church leaders need to create the context in which that happens, right? So you can call these men to engage and connect with these kids as they're growing up, but what programs, what opportunities are being created for that to actually happen on the ground, right? So for example, I think, and I've spoken at men's retreats that do this, every men's retreat should have the middle school and the high school boys on the retreat. Every women's retreat should have the high school and middle school girls on the retreat, stuff like that, right?

I know churches that do a really good job of having like a father-daughter dance, right? They may have like a mother-son brunch. Little things like that to foster that greater connection between parents and their children. And so those are the kind of programs that work, and here's what I'm not going to do. I don't really give a short list of things that every church should do because I think it just depends on the cultural context, right? The stuff that's going to work in downtown Detroit isn't going to work necessarily in LA or in Boca Raton in Florida. But what really matters and what was really important is how do we think more about the intergenerational relationships and fostering that in such a way that leads to greater connection across the generations between parents and their kids, and then adults and the rest of the kids in the church.

And so I think pastors have a real opportunity to be creative, to go kind of early church, maybe kind of Acts 2:42 on this, right? To kind of go back to sort of OG kind of Christianity, if I wanted to use that phrase, and do something really radical for the sake of families thriving, marriages thriving, and kids thriving. And again, I just think the church is the absolute perfect place for that because fathers can come in many forms. You can have a biological father, you can have an uncle, a grandfather, a father figure, a mentor, spiritual director. And so we need to get these men to get engaged. So quit wintering in Phoenix. Stop spending four months playing golf in Boca, right? Yes, go take your cruise, but come back. We need you to be engaged.

And one of the things that I tell men is simply this: do not complain about what you see in the lives of millennials and Gen Z-ers if you're not mentoring or discipling one of them, right? If you're going to complain, then invest. If you're going to protest, then invest. Otherwise, just be quiet, because there are a few of us who are rolling up our sleeves and spending our time, talent, and treasure trying to work on these issues.

And I think that invitation is simply this: brothers, we need you. We need your power, your strength, your presence, your time, your talent. We need you because one of the things that you may not know, gentlemen, is that you have a lot to offer. And if you don't think you have a lot to offer, take a kid, take a 20-year-old to lunch who didn't have a dad, and watch what happens. If you don't think you have a lot to offer, grab a 28-year-old who's never had a dad in his life and go play golf with him, right? If you don't think you matter, test it out, and I promise you, you have way more to offer than you realize. So we need to encourage them, right? Kind of call them in off the sidelines, off the pews, to get involved in the lives of these kids because the kids will benefit, but also they will as well.

[00:35:13] Stetzer: Anthony Bradley. I've known Anthony, I don't know, for 20 years ago we were probably speaking at an event together. His book is "The Fatherhood Effect: Consequences of a Dad-Deprived Culture and Practical Strategies for Positive Change." Thanks for being on "The Exchange" with Ed Stetzer.

[00:35:29] Bradley: Thanks for having me.